[ad_1]
On this “Face the Nation” broadcast, moderated by Margaret Brennan:
- Dr. Christos Christou, Medical doctors With out Borders Worldwide president
- Nationwide Safety Adviser Jake Sullivan
- Sen. Mark Warner, Democrat of Virginia, chair of the Senate Intelligence committee
- Rep. Michael McCaul, Republican of Texas, Home International Affairs committee chair
- Isaac Herzog, President of Israel
Click on right here to browse full transcripts of “Fac the Nation.”
MARGARET BRENNAN: I am Margaret Brennan in Washington.
And this week on Face the Nation: stress on Israel for a cease-fire, even a humanitarian pause, will increase, whereas the circumstances contained in the Gaza Strip proceed to deteriorate.
Israel’s efforts to decimate Hamas proceed, however the humanitarian scenario and escalating Palestinian civilian dying toll have intensified the protests world wide, as some Gazans try to flee the hardest-hit components of the area. Others wrestle to remain alive in areas which might be underneath assault and operating out of sources.
We may have stories from the area, and we’ll converse with White Home Nationwide Safety Adviser Jake Sullivan and Israeli President Isaac Herzog. Plus, Home International Affairs Committee Chairman Mike McCaul joins us from Tel Aviv.
Then: There are some vibrant spots for Democrats following final week’s off- 12 months elections. Can they win on points, regardless of an unpopular president?
Virginia Democratic Senator Mark Warner joins us.
It is all simply forward on Face the Nation.
Good morning, and welcome to Face the Nation.
We start the sixth week following Hamas’ brutal assault during which 1,200 Israelis died. That quantity has been dropped from 1,400, in response to the Israeli authorities, as stays are nonetheless being recognized.
Negotiations over releasing the 200-plus hostages proceed behind the scenes. Publicly, it is a battle that features allegations, counterallegations, and disturbing pictures. We’ll proceed to do our greatest to deliver you solely factual info and context.
We wish to start our protection immediately with Debora Patta, reporting from East Jerusalem.
(Start VT)
DEBORA PATTA (voice-over): They got here of their hundreds, chanting, “Now, now,” Israelis demanding the quick launch of the almost 240 family members kidnapped by Hamas on October 7, a reminder, in relation to ache, there aren’t any winners after greater than 5 weeks of battle.
In Gaza Metropolis, fierce street-to-street battles round a number of hospitals, together with the most important, Al Shifa, now a entrance line. Hole-eyed medical doctors and nurses work in torchlight in a well being system that’s on its knees. They got here to avoid wasting lives, however worry that, along with their sufferers, they might die right here.
Dr. Mohammed Obeid despatched out this desolate message.
DR. MOHAMMED OBEID (Surgeon): And so they hit these individuals many occasions. The scenario, as I mentioned earlier than, very, very dangerous. We’re almost certain that we’re alone now. Nobody hear us.
DEBORA PATTA: Medical employees need ensures that the round 600 sufferers nonetheless inside may be safely evacuated.
The Israeli army has saved up its drumbeat of accusations. Hamas, it says, is utilizing the hospital as an working base, a cost the group denies. Palestinians proceed to flee southwards, however it’s a perilous journey.
“My son was shot useless within the chest,” Ghaith Hasune (sp?) sobs. “I needed to go away his physique behind.”
(GHAITH HASUNE SPEAKING IN FOREIGN LANGUAGE)
DEBORA PATTA: And after they do attain the south, even so far as Rafah, the bombs proceed to fall.
(MAN SPEAKING IN FOREIGN LANGUAGE)
DEBORA PATTA: “We’re not concerned. We do not have fighters in our home,” this man weeps. “I simply function a donkey cart.”
That is the true price of this battle, hundreds of civilians killed, typically with solely a quantity to establish them, males, ladies and kids now being buried in anonymous mass graves.
(Finish VT)
DEBORA PATTA: And the Israeli army says it is now opened an evacuation route from the Al Shifa Hospital.
However, Margaret, for most of the sufferers there in a essential situation, that is merely not attainable.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Our Debora Patta.
CBS Information producer Marwan Al Ghoul filed this report final evening from Gaza.
(Start VT)
MARWAN AL GHOUL: In Gaza Metropolis, there are increasingly more extreme struggling. It is a matter of die or life in Gaza Metropolis, as no sufficient meals, no electrical energy, no gasoline in any respect.
But when I wish to speak about Gaza Metropolis, I’ve to speak about Al Shifa Hospital. This hospital incorporates 500 medical beds, however all occupied by injured individuals and sick as nicely. These displaced individuals stay within the hospital and the courtyards.
I had a name cellphone with Dr. Samir Al-Bosh (sp?), who advised me that scent of deaths all over the place within the hospitals, as there are 100 useless our bodies within the hospital. However they do not know the place to bury these our bodies, which tried, the administrations of the hospital, to dig mass grave to bury the our bodies over there.
Dr. Samir mentioned that the hospital and medical doctors can not apply any providers to the injured individuals, as no gasoline, no electrical energy, and every part ran out.
(Finish VT)
MARGARET BRENNAN: Producer Marwan Al Ghoul reporting from Gaza.
Christos Christou is president of Medical doctors With out Borders Worldwide, and he joins us now from Rome.
I perceive a lot of your medical doctors are working at Al Shifa Hospital, and mentioned two infants died on account of lack of electrical energy, the lack to maintain incubators on. There are 40 untimely infants who have to evacuate. Will the Israeli army assist these youngsters evacuate?
DR. CHRISTOS CHRISTOU (Worldwide President, Medical doctors With out Borders): To this point, we haven’t any information about any coordinated motion about evacuating no less than these neonate sufferers.
And we haven’t any information about any correct evacuation. What we see are a whole lot of sufferers that they’ve underwent surgical procedure very quickly and – very lately, and now they can’t be simply – take and stroll out of the hospital.
And subsequent to them, we’ve got new child infants that they wanted – untimely infants that they wanted help. They had been presupposed to be in incubators. No incubator works this second in Al Shifa. And, truly, Al Shifa would not work. It isn’t practical.
MARGARET BRENNAN: The prime minister of Israel has mentioned there is not any motive why we will not simply take the sufferers out of the hospital.
What’s your response to that?
DR. CHRISTOS CHRISTOU: To evacuate – to evacuate the hospital, you want time. You want weeks. It isn’t inside 24 hours.
And we mentioned that a number of occasions up to now additionally, that it takes quite a lot of good group to evacuate the hospital. And subsequent to this coordination, it takes additionally a cease-fire. We’ve got stories that individuals making an attempt to go away the hospital even have been shot down.
MARGARET BRENNAN: By who?
DR. CHRISTOS CHRISTOU: And we had additionally accidents – snipers. And we do not – and we do not know what is going on additionally typically contained in the hospital in a number of locations the place they’re bombed. There are airstrikes within the hospitals as nicely.
MARGARET BRENNAN: The Israeli army denies attacking the hospital advanced. I do know it is a big advanced.
However they declare that Hamas, as , has a command middle in that hospital. I understand you’re talking about very delicate issues, however the lives of your employees are additionally at risk right here. How does this get resolved?
DR. CHRISTOS CHRISTOU: To start with, we have to perceive that, at this proper second inside hospitals are individuals – are individuals in want, our sufferers, our kids.
Our kids, we’ve got this acronym, the WCNSF, wounded youngsters of non- surviving households. We’ve got a number of households that they’re there. And these are sufferers. We have to perceive that. We’ve got to guard the hospitals. Any assault within the medical care in the meanwhile is an assault on humanity.
MARGARET BRENNAN: However Israel’s army goes to go at that hospital whether it is certainly Hamas’ command middle. I am certain you perceive that.
You say it might take weeks to get everybody out. Is there any planning?
DR. CHRISTOS CHRISTOU: Nicely, there is not any planning. Everybody now lives – even – even the well being staff have been so overwhelmed and exhausted. And they’re ready in the meanwhile that they can not even provide something.
So, sure, what appears extra possible will not be a correct evacuation, however it’s a panic, is a panic that can find yourself with rubbles.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Permitting gasoline in has been an enormous sticking level for Israel, which worries that Hamas will get the gasoline. You want the gasoline to maintain the mills on.
Do you will have any supply of gasoline to maintain the electrical energy on, to maintain these individuals alive?
DR. CHRISTOS CHRISTOU: For the time being, there is not any gasoline within the hospital. And we run out of gasoline additionally in different hospitals.
And I can not converse on behalf of all of the hospitals this proper second in Gaza. I do know that there is not any electrical energy. We wouldn’t have connection in Web. All these testimonies that you simply get additionally from our colleagues like Dr. Mohammed Obeid earlier than was from yesterday.
We misplaced contact later at evening. We do not know what is going on on this proper second. And we all know since a very long time that individuals wouldn’t have even entry to drinkable water.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Mm-hmm.
It’s – I do not even have the phrases to reply to what you simply laid out, Physician. However thanks. And we want your medical doctors nicely, together with their sufferers.
DR. CHRISTOS CHRISTOU: Thanks, Margaret.
MARGARET BRENNAN: We’re joined now by White Home Nationwide Safety Adviser Jake Sullivan.
Jake, welcome again to this system.
The preventing appears very intense in and round Gaza. Medical doctors With out Borders has known as on the Israeli authorities to – quote – “finish its unrelenting assault on Gaza’s well being system.”
Does the U.S. consider that that is an correct description of what is occurring? Is the U.S. telling Israel to not hit hospitals?
JAKE SULLIVAN (U.S. Nationwide Safety Adviser): Nicely, Margaret, with out entering into intelligence info, we will simply take a look at the open-source reporting that Hamas is utilizing hospitals, because it makes use of many different civilian amenities, for command and management, for weapons storage, to deal with its fighters.
And this can be a violation of the legal guidelines of battle.
That being mentioned, Margaret, the USA doesn’t wish to see firefights in hospitals, the place harmless individuals, sufferers receiving medical care are caught within the crossfire. And we have had energetic consultations with the Israeli Protection Forces on this.
Actually, simply yesterday, the Israeli Protection Forces themselves mentioned that they – on the document, publicly, mentioned that they’re on the lookout for methods to have the ability to guarantee the protection and safety of particular person sufferers in these hospitals, whereas in addition they strive to determine a method to take care of the truth that Hamas is working in a means that is outdoors the sure – bounds of any civilized idea of how you’d consider using a hospital, utilizing human shields.
So it is an energetic dialog, however the backside line is, we do not wish to see firefights in hospitals.
MARGARET BRENNAN: OK.
You do not dispute, then, the Israeli assertion that Hamas has a command middle beneath Al Shifa Hospital?
NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISER JAKE SULLIVAN: I am not going to get into a selected assertion associated to a selected hospital, as a result of that may be entering into intelligence issues.
However, broadly talking, we will see from open-source reporting that there’s a monitor document, a sample of Hamas traditionally and on this battle utilizing hospitals and different civilian amenities for these functions.
MARGARET BRENNAN: I wish to ask you concerning the hostages, roughly 240, nonetheless being held by Hamas.
We had the chance to talk with Congressman Mike McCaul from Israel, the place he had simply met with the Israeli prime minister. And he advised us that Israel is contemplating Hamas’ proposal that Israel launch Palestinian ladies and kids from jail to be able to get hold of the hostages held by Hamas.
Is that one thing the U.S. thinks ought to occur?
NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISER JAKE SULLIVAN: Nicely, Margaret, you may perceive if I am very cautious in how I reply this query, as a result of the negotiations are delicate. They’re high-stakes.
What’s at stake is the restoration of a major variety of harmless individuals, together with harmless People, at present being held hostage by Hamas, a murderous terrorist group. It’s the case that there are energetic negotiations underneath means between Israel and Qatar, who’s speaking with Hamas, and the USA is concerned in these discussions, very a lot concerned in these discussions.
However I am not going to get into the specifics of what is on the desk, solely to say that we’re actively working to make sure the protected return of each American being held hostage and each different individual being held hostage by Hamas.
MARGARET BRENNAN: There are nonetheless roughly 400 People caught in Gaza, in response to the State Division. Will they get out?
NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISER JAKE SULLIVAN: We’re decided to make sure that they get out.
Many have gotten out. Many are nonetheless there, as you talked about, not simply Americans, but in addition their quick members of the family. And we’re making an attempt to create a circumstance the place each one among them can get protected passage out of Gaza. The gate has been open and closed. The lists have included People some days and never different days.
However the backside line is, immediately, the gate is open. We’re transferring Americans and their members of the family out. And within the days forward, we hope to make sure that each American who desires to go away Gaza is in a position to take action safely.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Jake, this previous week, a prime State Division official testified to Congress that the Gaza Well being Ministry’s estimates of 11,000 Palestinian useless might in actual fact be an undercount.
Does the White Home share that evaluation?
NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISER JAKE SULLIVAN: We do not have constancy on the numbers of casualties, fatalities in Gaza. We do not know what number of are fighters and what number of are harmless civilians.
However, as I’ve mentioned earlier than, and as Secretary Blinken has mentioned earlier than, we do know there are millions of harmless civilians who’ve been killed within the army operations that started after October 7. And each lack of lifetime of an harmless individual, whether or not it is Palestinian, Israeli, anybody, is an absolute tragedy.
And we grieve for each a kind of lives. And we proceed to bolster the proposition that Israel has the proper, certainly, the accountability to go after Hamas who continues to characterize a menace to the State of Israel. But it surely should achieve this in a means that is in keeping with the legal guidelines of battle.
MARGARET BRENNAN: And Secretary Blinken additionally mentioned too many Palestinians had died thus far.
I wish to zero in on the long run, which I do know you will have talked about from day one, what’s going to occur in Gaza subsequent. And you have pressed the Israeli authorities on this level.
Secretary Blinken has been clear that it is the West Financial institution and Gaza that must be underneath unified management, and the Palestinian – Palestinian Authority more likely to govern that. It would not sound just like the Netanyahu authorities is on the identical web page because the Biden administration, as a result of the prime minister mentioned one thing very totally different simply yesterday.
NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISER JAKE SULLIVAN: Nicely, from our perspective, the way in which ahead – the essential ideas of the way in which ahead are easy.
And that is one thing that Secretary Blinken laid out publicly this previous week, no reoccupation of Gaza, no forcible displacement of the Palestinian individuals. Gaza can by no means be used as a base for terrorism sooner or later. And Gaza’s territory shouldn’t be diminished.
Secretary Blinken additionally mentioned that, finally, we do wish to see the reconnection, the reunification of management between the West Financial institution and Gaza underneath Palestinian management. The Palestinian Authority is the present management on the West Financial institution.
However, finally, it is going to be as much as the Palestinian individuals to resolve their future, who governs them. And the USA will help a course of…
MARGARET BRENNAN: There have not been elections held in ages.
NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISER JAKE SULLIVAN: Nicely, that is proper, Margaret. There have not been elections held for the reason that early 2000s.
However, post-October 7, we will not return to the way in which issues had been on October 6. And that goes for making certain that Hamas can not characterize a unbroken menace to Israel. And, in actual fact, Hamas spokespeople have mentioned they wish to repeat October 7 repeatedly till Israel is worn out, that they wish to be in a everlasting state of battle with Israel.
That was on the entrance web page of “The New York Occasions”…
MARGARET BRENNAN: Sure.
NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISER JAKE SULLIVAN: … out of the mouth of a Hamas spokesman.
So, Israel goes to prosecute this marketing campaign in opposition to a terrorist group. However we can also’t return to October 6 in relation to governance.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Sure.
NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISER JAKE SULLIVAN: And it’ll finally be as much as or ought to be as much as the Palestinian individuals to resolve what their future governance seems like. And that ought to contain a reconnection, as Secretary Blinken has mentioned, of the West Financial institution and the Gaza Strip.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Jake Sullivan, thanks to your time.
Face the Nation shall be again in a single minute. Stick with us.
(ANNOUNCEMENTS)
MARGARET BRENNAN: And we’re again now with Senate Intelligence Committee Chairman Mark Warner of the state of Virginia.
And the Democrats had been – had been celebrating what occurred in Virginia this previous week along with your elections.
You mentioned it was – you advised the White Home what occurred in Virginia was the primary election of the 2024 nationwide election cycle.
What do you imply by that?
SENATOR MARK WARNER (D-Virginia): Nicely, I meant that, whereas there was quite a lot of concentrate on the Wisconsin Supreme Court docket race, the Ohio abortion query, in Virginia, a purple state, the place not solely abortion, however gun rights, voting rights had been all on the poll, when it comes to Democrats’ positions versus the Republicans.
And I feel it units the stage nicely for the president. And I feel one of many issues that has not gotten into the evaluation – I imply, clearly abortion was an enormous concern, however I additionally suppose Virginia very reliant on the federal authorities, we’ve got quite a lot of protection institution, quite a lot of federal staff.
I feel the general craziness that is come out of the Home of Representatives left a message that, even when the Republicans in Virginia would attempt to seem average, I feel Virginians had been afraid, in the event that they bought whole management of the state authorities, it might be the extremists, the MAGA crowd, that may drive the bus, the identical means that is occurring, sadly, on the nationwide stage.
And I feel that performed into the Democrats, , taking again the Home, retaining the Senate and stopping a few of that agenda.
MARGARET BRENNAN: However the president’s personal approval score is low.
So, when individuals draw a direct line and say Democrats did nicely right here, so subsequently, a 12 months from now, President Biden’s coasting to victory, do you agree with that? Or do Democrats have a Biden drawback, provided that his approval scores are – should not excessive?
SENATOR MARK WARNER: Hear, the president’s approval scores are robust. I am the primary to acknowledge that.
However I additionally suppose the president has repeatedly mentioned, on the finish of the day, this isn’t a selection between Joe Biden and an ideal different, significantly if the selection is between Joe Biden and Donald Trump. I feel Virginians, I feel People will reject that.
MARGARET BRENNAN: That additionally comes all the way down to a query of enthusiasm and turnout, proper, in tight elections.
And we have seen some significantly younger progressives on this concern we have been speaking about, Israel and Gaza, be very vocal of their frustration. And in tight races, states like Michigan matter loads. And there are over 200,000 Muslim People in that state.
SENATOR MARK WARNER: Mm-hmm.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Do you see this divide on this concern hurting the president with Democrats?
SENATOR MARK WARNER: I feel it has a possible to.
And that is why I feel all of us are urging Israel – clearly, Israel has the proper to defend itself, has the proper to take out Hamas. Hamas is holding most of the Palestinians, individuals, utilizing them as shields.
However all of us noticed these pictures in your present immediately. They’re horrific. So, what Israel has to appreciate – and because of this we have been pushing for these pauses, why we have been pushing to make it possible for the settler violence on the West Financial institution is managed. It is a battle for hearts and minds for Israel, not only a army battle.
And people hearts and minds go throughout our nation. They go throughout the area. And if they’re – if there’s no more consideration about Palestinian casualties, you may see this already tragic occasion spill over into violence on the West Financial institution, popping out of Lebanon, and clearly making it tougher in America to keep up our conventional help for Israel.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Proper.
America is Israel’s primary arms vendor. That is what we do. So, does one thing want to vary, when it comes to this potential assist package deal that’s being debated within the Senate?
SENATOR MARK WARNER: Nicely, I feel questions have been raised about how this assist shall be used. I’ve raised a few of these questions privately.
We additionally need to pair that with humanitarian help. And that’s completely essential. We have, once more, seen these horrific pictures.
However I additionally suppose, as we take into consideration this package deal, we additionally want to appreciate – – I – I hear quite a lot of the Republicans who wish to bash Iran, bash Iran, bash Iran.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Mm-hmm.
SENATOR MARK WARNER: And I get it, all proper? The Iranians are dangerous guys.
However they then appear to overlook the connection between Iran and Russia. And a few of these exact same people who wish to assist Israel, however then wish to stroll away from Ukraine? I feel strolling away from Ukraine at the moment could be a historic mistake that may pay adverse repercussions actually for years to return.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Are you assured that package deal, Ukraine and Israel and border and Taiwan, can move?
SENATOR MARK WARNER: I am assured, if we will put all these items collectively. And I consider that, not solely cash, however we do have to make some coverage adjustments on border.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Sure.
SENATOR MARK WARNER: The satan’s within the particulars, however I feel, if we get that package deal mixed, it’s going to positively move.
MARGARET BRENNAN: We will take a break and are available again and discuss to you on the opposite facet of it.
So, please stick with us, Senator.
We’ve got extra Face the Nation.
(ANNOUNCEMENTS)
MARGARET BRENNAN: Yesterday, greater than 300,000 pro-Palestinian protesters marched by way of Central London, calling for a cease-fire within the Gaza Strip.
Far proper counterprotesters clashed with police, and virtually 100 individuals had been arrested for making an attempt to disrupt the principle demonstration.
(ANNOUNCEMENTS)
MARGARET BRENNAN: We shall be proper again with much more Face the Nation.
Stick with us.
(ANNOUNCEMENTS)
MARGARET BRENNAN: Welcome again to FACE THE NATION.
We proceed our dialog now with Senator Mark Warner of Virginia.
You, in your place as head of the Intelligence Committee, have been monitoring quite a lot of the competitors with China, significantly within the expertise house. The White Home appears to be very centered on establishing military-to-military ties with China. What are you expecting out of this summit with Xi Jinping?
SENATOR MARK WARNER: Nicely, I do suppose re-establishing these army ties and communications are essential as a result of we noticed once we shot down the Chinese language balloon, no one picked up the cellphone on the opposite finish. And in contrast to Russia, the place we have had 75 years of conflicts however a lot of back-channel communications, as a result of our – our contest with China is newer, we do not have that stage of communication, so I feel that is essential to be reestablished.
I additionally suppose the president must push President Xi on the persevering with mental property theft that some years accounts for near $500 billion of mental property being stolen. And I firmly consider, once we’ve seen no retreat from China when it comes to its stage of expertise funding, I completely consider that nationwide safety within the twenty first century is greater than tanks and weapons. It’s who wins the battle for synthetic intelligence and quantum computing and superior vitality. The extent of Chinese language funding, for instance, on uncommon earth minerals popping out of Africa is big. And we want to have the ability to counter that with America and with our pals.
MARGARET BRENNAN: So, our – you need guardrails, I think about, arrange with China on synthetic intelligence and the like, however legislating round quite a lot of that is actually exhausting and it is not transferring in a short time.
SENATOR MARK WARNER: Margaret, let me let you know, I did the invoice that was terribly bipartisan, 13 and 13, Democrats/Republicans –
MARGARET BRENNAN: Sure.
SENATOR MARK WARNER: About saying we want an method that is not merely centered on TikTok, however on all international expertise which may pose –
MARGARET BRENNAN: Proper.
SENATOR MARK WARNER: A nationwide safety threat from China or Russia or Iran. And all of a sudden we had the extremes on each the left and the proper come out in opposition to that laws. It wants to maneuver as a result of, significantly now as you see actually 40 p.c of younger individuals get all their information from TikTok. So I hope these sort of points shall be – we will get some vitality behind them now coming after this summit.
However this expertise competitors, we have had army rivals like Russia. We have by no means had an economic system that is making the investments the way in which China is in these new expertise domains.
MARGARET BRENNAN: So, Microsoft, this week, got here out with a report that mentioned Russia, Iran and China will intrude within the 2024 presidential race. Not – they had been sure about this. And different shut presidential races worldwide.
Is your laws going to cease one thing like that?
SENATOR MARK WARNER: I feel our laws will tackle a difficulty like a TikTok, which is, I’m afraid, may very well be used as a propaganda channel for the CCP, the Communist Get together of China. And my beef is with the CCP, it is not with the Chinese language individuals or the Chinese language deaspra (ph).
However round synthetic intelligence the place I feel we have to be humble as a result of candidly we have achieved nothing on any guardrails on social media and on expertise writ massive. The 2 areas the place synthetic intelligence might have an unlimited adverse impact tomorrow is interfering in our public elections, however it additionally might have a instrument when it comes to interfering in our public markets. And I have been shocked we have not seen extra manipulation, for instance, of shares utilizing AI instruments. So, my hope is, maybe we will get a coalition between those that favor ensuring our public markets should not interfered with in addition to those that had been involved about interference in our election to construct the sort of coalition as a result of taking over large tech –
MARGARET BRENNAN: Sure.
SENATOR MARK WARNER: I have been there for years and bought a – just about a zero document and no one in Congress has bought an excellent document on this. I feel we want that sort of coalition as a result of the election interference may very well be huge.
MARGARET BRENNAN: In a short time, is that “Washington Publish” report that Ukraine was behind the assault on Nord Stream correct and is attacking civilian infrastructure acceptable?
SENATOR MARK WARNER: Margaret, I am not going to touch upon something that comes out of categorized intelligence. We do know that Russia has a historical past of misinformation and disinformation, however we’ll proceed to comply with that concern.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Senator, thanks to your time immediately.
SENATOR MARK WARNER: Thanks.
MARGARET BRENNAN: And we spoke earlier immediately with the chairman of the Home International Affairs Committee, Michael McCaul, from Tel Aviv.
(BEGIN VT)
MARGARET BRENNAN: I do know you are wrapping up what has been a fairly fast and busy journey to Israel. You met with Prime Minister Netanyahu. Did you get a way that his authorities is near wrapping up this army operation?
REP. MICHAEL MCCAUL (R-TX): No, I do not suppose so. I feel it is – , the air strikes, I feel the bottom recreation is simply now beginning.
And I’ll say, Margaret, once we walked in, the very first thing we noticed was the horrific Hamas video exhibiting the ugly killings of those barbaric terrorists. And it was a really intense, sort of highly effective, second.
You already know, the prime minister was in tears. Actually teary-eyed about what occurred. And, keep in mind, that is form of like their 9/11. And so they – they wish to get rid of the menace, , as they need to. And I feel that – and we talked loads concerning the floor recreation operations, humanitarian, and we additionally met with the minister of protection as nicely.
MARGARET BRENNAN: And also you simply raised humanitarian assist. I do know the U.S. is the most important donor to the U.N. aid company that operates within Gaza. Many within the Republican caucus don’t help any assist going to them or to Palestinians, even Palestinian civilians dwelling in Gaza. Do you consider that the help package deal going by way of Congress wants to incorporate this sort of assist?
MICHAEL MCCAUL: Nicely, I do. And I feel the Israelis do as nicely. I feel, , I talked about this with the prime minister. They’ve put a buffer zone in the course of Gaza to create this humanitarian zone in southern Gaza. They opened up the Rafah gate, that is Egypt. About 100 vans a day are coming in. But it surely must be like meals, water, and medication. It could actually’t be gasoline as a result of Hamas can use that to mild their tunnels and function them.
MARGARET BRENNAN: There are nonetheless roughly 400 People caught within Gaza in response to the State Division. Did you get any replace on how they’re doing?
MICHAEL MCCAUL: We did. And really delicate negotiations with the Qataris. They’re sort of the lead dealer, if you’ll, of this negotiation. You already know, I am assembly with, proper after this interview, with a bunch of households of the hostages. And I met with them in the USA. Very dicey concern.
And I feel what Hamas desires could be a swap of prisoners in Israel of Palestinians in trade for these hostages, each People and Palestinians, within the Gaza. That is an ongoing factor. I hope it might occur. A cease-fire could be very tough with out an settlement to launch all hostages.
MARGARET BRENNAN: To be clear, are the Palestinian People who’re trapped in Gaza being included in that hostage negotiation? Is that what you are saying as nicely?
MICHAEL MCCAUL: No, this can be a –
MARGARET BRENNAN: OK.
MICHAEL MCCAUL: No, I am sorry, it is the Palestinian – Palestinians in – in jail in Israel which might be being, , negotiated in trade for prisoners of each Israelis and People held captive in Gaza.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Understood. In order that Hamas proposal is being entertained. Attention-grabbing to know that.
I wish to ask you about what Congress can ship when it comes to assist to Israel. Do you suppose that the brand new speaker of the Home has the clout vital along with your caucus to maneuver by way of a package deal that features Israel assist, Ukraine assist, and different nationwide safety objects?
MICHAEL MCCAUL: Our assist to Israel is pressing and time is of the essence. We’ve got to ship this package deal.
Now, I do know that we’ve got offsets, and that is honest, however I do not suppose we will play political video games with this to help our ally as a result of, , if – in the event that they fail, and we fail, it might have a really dangerous impact throughout the Center East.
Into Ukraine, that is vitally essential as nicely. So is Taiwan. And so is the final line of protection, the southern border. So, actually, if you concentrate on it, all these threats are actually tied collectively. Now, whether or not we deal with all of it altogether or individually with say Ukraine and border safety, all that has but to be discovered. The stage to, if you’ll, a CR that the speaker is making an attempt to implement, I feel will truly transfer the method ahead.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Nicely, that – that deadline when it comes to authorities funding is subsequent week, November seventeenth. Yesterday the speaker made this proposal, it is sort of an uncommon method to do it, known as a laddered, short-term funding deal.
MICHAEL MCCAUL: Proper.
MARGARET BRENNAN: The White Home says it is simply not severe and it is a waste of time. Are we going to see a authorities shutdown?
MICHAEL MCCAUL: Nicely, , we’ve got the facility of the purse. And, look, we want – we want extra time. The CRs all the time harm the army, all the time harm our nationwide safety. And so the primary CR till January might resolve the 4 – final 4 appropriation payments that we will not move thus far. So we might move these after which have till February to barter with the Senate to get this achieved and put it on the president’s desk. That may even give us time –
MARGARET BRENNAN: Proper, however first you want the votes to really move this. So – so can Republicans vote collectively to move this proposal, this short-term funding settlement?
MICHAEL MCCAUL: We will need to. I imply, there is not any selection right here. I imply the world is on hearth from the place I sit. It’s too, , pressing. We won’t sit again and do nothing. And speaking to Prime Minister Netanyahu, they wanted this yesterday, in his phrases. Ukraine wanted it yesterday. The border, for definitely, want it yesterday. And we all know that Chairman Xi is threatening Taiwan and the Pacific.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Sure.
MICHAEL MCCAUL: So, , I feel what the Senate’s going to do, they will give you a package deal, most likely after Thanksgiving, that they’ll ship over to the Home.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Proper. And we’ll see if that authorities funding proposal can get handed by subsequent week to keep away from that shutdown.
Congressman, thanks for becoming a member of us from Israel this morning.
We’ll be proper again.
(ANNOUNCEMENTS)
MARGARET BRENNAN: We flip now to the president of Israel, Isaac Herzog, who joins us from Jerusalem.
Good afternoon to you, sir.
ISAAC HERZOG (President of Israel): Good morning, Margaret.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Your nation misplaced 1,200 of its civilian residents on October the seventh. And I do know you are still reeling from that. However what we’re seeing in Gaza proper now with Hamas and this focus of very intense preventing round al-Shifa Hospital, if that’s certainly Hamas’ command middle, does that imply this battle ends in case you take management of it?
ISAAC HERZOG: Nicely, the battle we have – we have taken on in opposition to Hamas is a battle that – which issues to all the well-being and security of – of the world, I’d say, and subsequently our fundamental intention at this stage following the atrocities we have gone by way of on October seventh is to uproot the potential of Hamas. It would not finish in Shifa Hospital. They’re based mostly all all through Gaza.
MARGARET BRENNAN: I do know you will have personally met with most of the households of the roughly 240 hostages being held by Hamas and different terror teams. Are you able to clarify why Israel is reportedly now contemplating releasing Palestinian ladies and kids out of your prisons in trade for a few of these hostages held by Hamas?
ISAAC HERZOG: Nicely, I do not wish to give any illusions. Qatar is making an attempt to mediate. So is Egypt. So as to get a humanitarian launch of a – of a few of the hostages, we demand all of the hostages. That is the worldwide demand. However there are – there are talks, in fact, behind the scenes. I can not verify any particulars.
What I can say is that there’s nothing substantial proper now on the desk. The USA can also be closely concerned in it. So, there’s nothing tangible that I can report.
MARGARET BRENNAN: I requested as a result of up to now Israel has flatly refused that Hamas proposal to launch Palestinians from jail. Are you saying that is a false report?
ISAAC HERZOG: It isn’t the identical. It isn’t the identical. There are 4 dozens say that Israel is keen to launch our – murderers who’re sentenced for a life sentence. In my speech in Congress, to a joint session of the Home in – in July, mid-July –
MARGARET BRENNAN: Sure.
ISAAC HERZOG: I mentioned that all the drawback with the peace course of within the area is terror (ph). Terror is undermining all the capability to maneuver ahead. All of those that keep in mind a long time of making an attempt to make peace with our neighbors know that we will make tempo with those that adhere to the agreements and struggle terror. Sadly a nation, which helps and aides terror, we can’t be a accomplice.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Sure.
ISAAC HERZOG: And we have seen the atrocious outcomes.
MARGARET BRENNAN: I perceive. And the USA of America considers Hamas to be a terrorist group and has for – for many years. They’re very clear on that.
However as you simply talked about, you will have lengthy been an advocate for peace with the Palestinians, however there are various within the present authorities who earlier than October seventh weren’t and don’t favor two states for 2 individuals.
Do you continue to consider that’s the means finally to have peace.
ISAAC HERZOG: Why would anyone agree proper now to any progress with our neighbors once we do not see really their capability to struggle terror and lots of, a lot of them, together with these in Gaza, are hailing and smiling and celebrating in essentially the most atrocious means the world’s biggest atrocity virtually since World Struggle II.
Could I additionally add and let you know that a part of the entire concern is that it is sort of a tradition that celebrates these terrible atrocities.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Which tradition?
ISAAC HERZOG: These atrocities can’t be agreed – accepted in any means. It means it has nothing to do with the battle. It has nothing to do with the borders, with settlements or something. That is easy. Easy, clear, barbarism, Jew hate, different hate, which is advocated by ISIS, Hamas, al Qaeda, which, if we weren’t right here, then Europe shall be subsequent and doubtless the USA is the top recreation for all of them.
MARGARET BRENNAN: I perceive, and I am not discounting in any means anti- Semitism across the globe, which is on the rise.
When it comes particularly, although, to the long-term safety of the Democratic and Jewish state of Israel, it feels like you will have misplaced some hope for that peace course of. However I ponder, given what you’re seeing occur in Gaza proper now, and the want you will have for safety to your individuals, aren’t you involved that extra people shall be radicalized by the extent of civilian casualties proper now?
ISAAC HERZOG: If we eradicate the capabilities of Hamas, we’ll give hope to the Palestinians in Gaza too, to run their life decently, as we have anticipated within the accords we had with the Palestinians. We enabled the Palestinian Authority to take management of Gaza and so they misplaced it.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Sure.
ISAAC HERZOG: They misplaced it to a brutal coup of Hamas in 2007.
However the concern is, I saved on asking President Abbas of the Palestinian Authority in – on quite a few event, would you go in if Israel takes Hamas out? And he mentioned no. Now I do not know precisely the place he’s at and in the event that they’re even able to doing so. However one factor is evident, we at the start have to present security and safety to Israel.
MARGARET BRENNAN: Understood. However even the USA authorities says that dying toll of 11,000 Palestinians could also be an undercount. They are saying they can not separate civilians from Hamas fighters. But it surely’s nonetheless an amazing quantity of dying.
So, provided that, how are you going to say with certainty that Israel’s army and intelligence is hitting the proper targets proper now, that the dying that’s occurring is important and useful to your safety?
ISAAC HERZOG: I thanks for this query to begin with as a result of I wish to categorical my utter ache and sorrow for any harmless casualty on the Palestinian facet. We’re doing our utmost, in response to worldwide humanitarian regulation. Firstly, we alert individuals. I imply what is the story right here? The enemy, these terrorists, fought and tried to kill us and ship missiles and terrorists from their properties. So, we’ve got to go to those properties and we’ve got to explode all their infrastructure, tunnels, missile, every part.
So, we go and we despatched leaflets, we name and we cellphone and we ship textual content messages to all of the civilians in that space, we inform them transfer out, we give them time to maneuver out and we have opened humanitarian corridors and we’ve got elevated dramatically the humanitarian assist to those that are transferring out to a security zone.
Sadly, there may very well be casualties. A few of them are additionally by Hamas hearth. And their reporting and the numbers are unclear to me. However I am saying outright, we’re doing our greatest. Sadly, this stuff occur, and we’re sorry for it, however, on the finish of the day, we’ve got to uproot that infrastructure as a result of we’ve got to defend ourselves in response to our proper and obligation to defend our individuals.
MARGARET BRENNAN: President Herzog, thanks to your time.
(END VT)
MARGARET BRENNAN: We’ll be again in a second.
(ANNOUNCEMENTS)
MARGARET BRENNAN: Democrats celebrated a sequence of high-profile wins on this previous Tuesday’s elections, together with an abortion rights modification in Ohio and full management of the state legislature in Virginia. However there was one other notable consequence, liberals received a sequence of faculty board races in pink and blue states alike. Why?
This is chief White Home correspondent Nancy Cordes.
(BEGIN VT)
NANCY CORDES (voice over): When election season rolls round, faculty board races have not all the time gotten quite a lot of consideration.
WOMAN: If you are going to yell, simply do – get up, yell and go away.
NANCY CORDES (voice over): However that was earlier than faculty board hearings across the nation turned a flashpoint for fights over guide banning –
MAN: They’re molesting our children’ minds.
NANCY CORDES (voice over): Variety –
MAN: What am I being arrested for?
NANCY CORDES (voice over): And LGBTQ plus rights.
WOMAN: The film had not been accepted and it was not acceptable.
WOMAN: Know that you’re making Orlando (ph) County unsafe and an unproductive working and studying setting.
NANCY CORDES (voice over): 2021 noticed a surge in conservative faculty board candidates pushing again on pandemic-era faculty closures and masks mandates. This previous Tuesday, the pendulum appeared to swing the opposite means, with extra liberal candidates choosing up faculty board seats in states like Pennsylvania, Iowa, Ohio, and Virginia.
WOMAN: I began to see the results of a few of the chaos and disfunction on our faculty board in our school rooms.
NANCY CORDES (voice over): Valan Rodas (ph) is a instructor and newly elected faculty board member in Spotsylvania County, Virginia.
WOMAN: You are not going to chop my mic off once I go to vote.
NANCY CORDES (voice over): That board drew nationwide consideration in 2021 when it voted to tug what it known as sexually specific books from faculty libraries.
WOMAN: From there it simply appeared to proceed spiraling into different distracting tradition battle points that are not the issues which might be wanted – wanted addressing to assist our college students.
NANCY CORDES (voice over): On Tuesday, Spotsylvania’s faculty board flipped from a 4-3 conservative majority to 5-2 for progressives.
NANCY CORDES: What message do you suppose voters had been making an attempt to ship concerning the faculty board?
WOMAN: I consider they need us to work collectively.
NANCY CORDES (voice over): April Gillespie is among the two remaining conservatives.
WOMAN: I consider they’re uninterested in the preventing and the lawsuits and – on each side. Simply every part. Either side. I feel that they need us to maneuver ahead and concentrate on the enterprise of the division and never a lot the politics of issues.
NANCY CORDES (voice over): Final Tuesday’s faculty board races are being seen as a check case for 2024 when voters in all 50 states will go to the polls. Democrats are hoping this concern, like abortion, will assist to drive turnout and make up for what polls present is a dip in enthusiasm for the group on the prime of the ticket.
(END VT)
MARGARET BRENNAN: That is Nancy Cordes reporting.
We’ll be proper again.
(ANNOUNCEMENTS)
MARGARET BRENNAN: In the present day some tragic breaking information. The Pentagon has simply introduced that 5 U.S. service members had been killed yesterday in an plane coaching mission within the Mediterranean Sea. Our condolences to these households and our deepest respect and thanks for all of those that serve or have served within the army.
Till subsequent week, for FACE THE NATION, I am Margaret Brennan.
(ANNOUNCEMENTS)
[ad_2]
Source link